Order Sheet Part -1
Muni swamappa, since Dead By his L.Rs : Smt. Bhadramma & others. Aplpellants
of Karnataka , R-4 [karnataka Judicial Employees House Building Co-operative Society]
Order of court
Ag. CJ & RGRJ
1] Sri Papaiah and Sri Muniswamappa filed writ petition No. 3955 and 6156 of 1989 seeking quashing of the final notification No. RD/156/AQB/84 dated 24-2-1989 issued under section 6 of the Land Acquistion Act in so far as it relates to Sy .No. 91/5, 91/6, 91/2A and 111/3 belonging to the petitioners. The land had been acquired for karnataka Judicial Employees House Building Co-operative Society R-4. The writ petition was dismissed by the Single Judge on 17-11-1992. Against the order passed by the single judge, Muniswappa filed writ appeal No. 5699/97 along with I.A.1 to condone the delay in filing the appeal. The writ appeal was dismissed by the Division Bench on 24-10-1997 in terms of the order passed in WA. 4283/93 dated 17-11-1995 . Against the order passed by the Division Bench ; SLP(civil) 398/1998 was filed in the Supreme Court of India . The Supreme Court by its Order dated 08-10-1998 set aside the order of the High Court dismissing the appeal on the ground of delay. The matter was restored to the file of the High court with a request to decide the same at its earliest convenience after hearing the Parties .
2 ] Muniswamappa died & nine of his legal representatives were brought on record . Before the case could be taken up for final disposal on merits a compromise petition has been filed stating there in that the legal representatives of Muniswamappa and R-4 [karnataka Judicial Employees House Building Co-operative Society] have entered into a compromise . According to the compromise Respondent No. 4 has agreed to give 13 sites in lieu of the land acquired belonging to Muniswamappa . It was stated that the Writ Appeal may be disposed of in terms of compromise petition .
3 ] There are
Nine legal representatives and they could be allotted only one site in lieu of the land
acquired from Muniswamappa . We fail to understand as to how 13 sites are being allotted
in lieu of the claim made by Muniswamappa in addition to the compensation paid for the
land acquired . We decline to record the compromise as it is not in the interest of the
Society [ R-4 ] . Copy of this Order be placed for Discussion and Deliberation before
the Executive Committee as well as before the General Body Meeting of the Society .
Ag Chief Justice .